• Elliot Temple
  • Berkeley, California
  • Email:
  • AIM: curi42
  • Blog
  • RSS

I am an American, atheist, libertarian, and philosopher. I like William Godwin, Karl Popper, David Deutsch, Richard Feynman, Ayn Rand, and Edmund Burke.

Godwin

Fallible Ideas

Dialogs

Blog Archives

Recent Comments

[Previous] Popper on Burke and Tradition | Home | [Next] Relationships Lack Error Correction

Voltaire is Terrible

http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Voltaire
If you want good laws, burn those you have and make new ones.
In fact, destroying knowledge is not a method of creating knowledge, let alone of creating superior knowledge.
Elliot Temple at 11:28 AM on January 18, 2010 | Permalink

Comments

Oh, come on. How could you hate a man who wrote, "A witty saying proves nothing?"

I think you're taking the prima facie reading of this quotation to heart. It's clear that he was writing metaphorically, as he often did.

And how do laws represent accumulated knowledge? All they represent is accumulated opinion, which is subject to human fallibility.

If anything, he was rejecting the implicit veracity of tradition.
lz0 at 6:28 PM on January 29, 2010 | Permalink
So our laws don't contain more knowledge of how to have a peaceful society than, say, ancient Roman laws?

Of course it's a metaphor. He doesn't mean burn them, he means throw them out, disregard them, ignore them, and start from scratch. Starting from scratch is exactly the wrong way to create good laws.
Elliot at 7:04 PM on January 29, 2010 | Permalink

Post A Comment

No HTML.