[Previous] Children Becoming Independent | Home | [Next] One Truth and Parenting and Morality

Hitting in Education

Schools used to hit people who got an answer wrong.

Hitting people for being wrong is very un-Popperian!

A) it doesn't help them create knowledge
B) mistakes are common (among everyone, adults too)
C) finding mistakes is good! they should celebrate. why connect it to pain?
D) they see the problem like this:

we KNOW the answer. the difficulty is how to suppress disagreement (which must be bad, because it's mistaken, b/c it contradicts the KNOWN TRUTH). in other words, we know what ideas should rule, and the only thing left is to enforce their rule.

of course Popper would prefer this problem: we have some ideas about the answer, and they may be mistaken, and by discussion with people who disagree, and culture clash, and self-reflection, and criticism, and by a serious effort, we may learn something about our mistakes, and come nearer to the truth.

Elliot Temple on January 2, 2009

Messages (2)

Hi Elliot

I'd really like it if you could set up some sort of RSS feed so I can view your blog on my iGoogle home page :)

tarasita@googlemail (dot) com

Anonymous at 4:22 AM on January 11, 2009 | #1719 | reply | quote

Anonymous at 9:31 AM on January 11, 2009 | #1720 | reply | quote

Want to discuss this? Join my forum.

(Due to multi-year, sustained harassment from David Deutsch and his fans, commenting here requires an account. Accounts are not publicly available. Discussion info.)