[Previous] roleplaying is surprisingly fundamental | Home | [Next] Bad/Evil

pasting from aim is easy :-)

curi42 (9:25:42 AM): there's 2 main approaches (plus a mixture is possible too): 1) absolutely ignore everything false or stupid the person says, and just write about better ideas and better ways to think and live. hopefully he'll see the good in them, like them, adopt some, and eventually he'll realise he doesn't act on his old, crap theories any longer (or maybe he *won't* ever notice the change, but will act good)
curi42 (9:27:01 AM): 2) criticism! i'm sure we could make a nice list of 50 reasons his ideas don't work. the premises are flawed in lots of ways. even if the premises were true, his conclusions still wouldn't follow. he contradicts hismelf repeatedly. etc etc etc
curi42 (9:27:40 AM): style 2 seems to have bad results with most people (though perhaps something similar to style 2, that somehow takes into account detailed knowledge of the person, would work very well)
curi42 (9:27:59 AM): but style 1 is easy to ignore.

Elliot Temple on November 9, 2003

Messages (2)

If only every took the stance: "I may be wrong and you may be right and by an effort we may get nearer to the truth." – Karl Popper

Nic Babb at 10:03 PM on November 10, 2003 | #134 | reply | quote

where exactly is Nic Babb's effort to get nearer to the truth?

Anonymous at 5:51 PM on January 5, 2017 | #8180 | reply | quote

Want to discuss this? Join my forum.

(Due to multi-year, sustained harassment from David Deutsch and his fans, commenting here requires an account. Accounts are not publicly available. Discussion info.)